Subaru Crosstrek and XV Forums banner

Just finished putting a dual-range gearbox in my 2012 XV

11K views 30 replies 10 participants last post by  ApocalypsePopcorn  
#1 · (Edited)
Success video.

I bought this car earlier this year with a 6 speed manual, and the back-of-my-mind idea that I might attempt this swap one day, but then the clutch died, so I figured it was now or never.
I dropped in a 1.447:1 5sp low range box from a 2006 EJ20 liberty/legacy. It wasn't a simple job, and I kept finding extra parts I needed to source along the way.

I used this site to help in the search for an appropriate box.

Subaru offered a few ratios of low range, with 1.447 being the one with most reduction. It's not as good as a proper off-road rig, but a quick drive into the hills next to my place showed a big improvement over perviously. Most importantly, I'll be less likely to get myself into a scenario where I have to float the clutch to get up a hill and get home (source of the original issue).

I put an Exedy heavy duty clutch in it, just to be safe.

I also had to match the rear diff to the new box's 4.111 ratio (the original had been 4.44, I believe). There's also a transfer gear which can either be 1:1 or 1:1.1 I believe. Mine was 1:1 so front and rear diff ratios needed to be the same.

Removing the exhaust, gearbox, drive shaft and rear diff were surprisingly straightforward with no surprises.

I also made the job harder by not having a flat area to do it on. Rather than risk having the car fall on me, I put the front wheels on ramps on my sloped driveway, and managed to remove and replace both gearbox and rear diff without removing the wheels and axles. I don't recommend this, since it was a pain in the arse and one CV came unassembled and had to be put back together. But it is possible. Also, I did this without assistance, and creative use of a winch really helped me getting the gear box up and down.

The gearbox did bolt straight up with no problems.

The 6 speed is cable-shift, whereas the dual-range is direct. Luckily the chassis has bolt holes for the gear stick mounting bush. The gear stick does sit pretty low compared to before, but it works and I definitely like the feel of the direct shift better than the sloppy cables.

The biggest hassle was the starter motor. The EJ20 starter is physically smaller, so the XV's starter wouldn't fit (though the bolt holes are the same). The EJ starter I got wouldn't mate with the FB flywheel because the EJ starter's gear is smaller than the FB. So I disassembled them both, planning to swap gears, but the FB starter's pinion gear is also longer, so after cutting it down to size and installing it in the EJ starter, and putting it back together, it almost worked. The alignment was slightly off, so I shimmed the starter to angle it ever so slightly, and now it engages. It's a bit "creative", but by this stage I really didn't want to source a new flywheel, have it surfaced, potentially have to get a new clutch kit and then hope that it all worked together.
Lesson: If you're going to do this, use an EJ flywheel and get the starter motor, low range lever and cable, centre console and gear lever all together from the same donor car.

The cable from the low range lever to the gearbox was also about 10cm too short, so I had to make up a bit of an adapter.

I'm lucky that in Australia there are low-range manual cars I can source parts from for a project like this. In the US, I believe the main option is to get a built low range gearbox from AllDriveSubaru in Sydney (somewhere in the $3k range) which some US importers will bring in.
I could have driven to AllDriveSubaru, but I don't have that sort of cash for a project like this so I pieced it together myself.
I did lose access to a sensor on the 6 speed gearbox that tells the computer what gear you're in, so I guess we'll see how things go on the open road.

I'm sure I've forgotten a bunch of stuff, but hopefully this can be of some guidance to anyone considering doing the same.

Image


Image


Image


Image


Image


Image
 
#7 ·
Update: I've driven her for a few days with the new gearbox now. For light off-roading the low range makes a world of difference. It won't crawl like a proper 4x4, but I'm much better able to handle steeper trails, and negotiate tricky bits at a slower speed. 66% of normal, to be precise.
I also filled the tank with 98ron (only ever used 91ron before) and the extra bit of oomph makes up a bit for the lack of low-end torque this engine has.
The gearbox is miles better. The solid feedback of a direct shift linkage rather than the slop of cable shift is much nicer, and the five gears are much more usefully spaced in gearing (at least, that's how it feels to this guy who's used to 5 speed manual Toyotas).
This is the gearbox the XV should have had.
The stick I've got does sit a bit more forward and low down than I'm comfortable with. Perhaps there's an Impreza gear shift mechanism that would sit better. For now though it's fine.
 
#8 ·
Update: I've driven her for a few days with the new gearbox now. For light off-roading the low range makes a world of difference. It won't crawl like a proper 4x4, but I'm much better able to handle steeper trails, and negotiate tricky bits at a slower speed. 66% of normal, to be precise.
I also filled the tank with 98ron (only ever used 91ron before) and the extra bit of oomph makes up a bit for the lack of low-end torque this engine has.
The gearbox is miles better. The solid feedback of a direct shift linkage rather than the slop of cable shift is much nicer, and the five gears are much more usefully spaced in gearing (at least, that's how it feels to this guy who's used to 5 speed manual Toyotas).
This is the gearbox the XV should have had.
The stick I've got does sit a bit more forward and low down than I'm comfortable with. Perhaps there's an Impreza gear shift mechanism that would sit better. For now though it's fine.
“This is the gearbox the XV should have had”

for your extreme use of crawling through hills, maybe. But the vehicle likely gets 20mpg now, almost assuredly will not be problem free for over 100k miles, and is a Frankenstein of parts not meant to hook together…

I think it’s a really cool project, and I’m impressed with what you’ve done! That doesn’t mean that it’s the gearbox the vehicle should have been manufactured with though. Subaru took infinite more factors and situations into account and mated the best transmission and engine options they make to provide a reliable drivetrain for MOST reasonable uses.
 
#11 ·
Just wanted to do a quick update after two weeks. Everything is running well. I did have a leaky front axle seal (just the right side) but I swapped that out ($30aud from Subaru btw) and a few days of parking over cardboard shows no drips, so I'm confident that was a bad seal on my "new" gearbox and not any sort of incompatibility.
Fuel consumption according to the screen is 8.8l/100km (26.73mpg) over the last 700km or so, which again is a mix of town, off-road and (I said highway before, but actually it's the winding, hilly, single lane 100kph/60mph rural road I take to get into town). This is about the same as before.
In my experience with the 6mt, the 6th gear only really made sense on flat 110kph/70mph highways, which where I live is basically just the insterstate and I only do I trip on that once or twice a year. I also really hated the gearing on second gear. Though the whole point of this swap was to get dual range, I am finding that I much prefer the 5mt gear spacing for the driving I do, and the ratio of 5th gear is perfect for the highest speeds I do (still have to downshift on significant hills).
In addition to off-road use, I find myself using low range on occasion around town during hill starts. I feel like it takes a bit of the strain off the clutch, since the XV has ****-all low rev torque, which means to not stall you need higher revs before and a longer transition to engagement, and I don't like that for the clutch.
I'll be getting a scanner tool at some point, but so far I haven't noticed the car doing anything weird that suggests it's confused about the different gearbox.
 
#14 ·
Congratulations on the successful installation of the Dual Range Transmission.
With the next few sentences I would like to tease the American members of the forum a tiny bit, because in the USA the XV/Crosstrek was never offered with dual range.:giggle:
I've had the feeling of driving off-road that you now have with the installation of the dual-range transmission since 2005 with my first Subaru, an Impreza. And all of the following three Subarus, 2007 Forester SG, 2011 Forester SH, 2017 XV/Crosstrek continued to let me drive through the terrain with dual range and a big grin when hunting friends with other cars had problems there.
Unfortunately, there are no more new Subarus with dual-range transmissions in Europe either.
But I have to say that based on my experience so far with my current XV/Crosstrek 2023 with CVT, the X-Mode replaces the dual range reduction quite well.
 
#15 ·
Sorry, did you say your 2017 XV came with a dual range? I thought I'd heard about some early models in Europe having them, but it's cool to get confirmation. Is it direct shift or cable shift, do you know? In Australia the XV never came with dual range as an option, but access to the many other Subarus that did made this a viable swap.
I feel sorry for the Americans always having automatics shoved down their throats.
Having looked at Toyota's Hybrid CVT (beltless), I look forward to them integrating that into a crosstrek and buying one used in a decade or so.
 
#16 ·
Since its launch, the XV has been offered in Europe with 2 engines, 1.6L and 2.0L. Only the 1.6 was available up to and including 2017 with 5MT and Dual Range, the 2.0 had CVT.
When I was looking for a replacement for my Forester 2.0 SH 2011 in 2017, the dual range reduction was so important to me that I even accepted the smaller 1.6 engine for the XV/Crosstrek, because the Forester was also only available with a CVT in Germany in 2017.
I chose the XV/Crosstrek 1.6 again this year because the 2.0 in Germany is only available as a hybrid, called the 2.0ie. As a hybrid, however, the XV/Crosstrek has a tank of only 48 l due to the battery in the trunk. That's not enough for my purposes and only the 1.6 with CVT was left again.
But as with the previous 1.6 5MT Dual Range, the 1.6's 114hp is more than enough, even on the German highways, which in parts still have no speed limit - my previous 1.6 managed real 185km/h with 114hp.
I don't know for sure, but I suspect my 2017 XV/Crosstrek had direct shift on the normal gears. Only dual range was cable shift. But like I said, that's a guess.
 
#18 ·
Absolutely correct, especially since speed limits apply everywhere on American roads, including freeways, my own experience.
And the penalties for exceeding them are also quite high, also from my own experience.
What's the use of an engine with a lot of horsepower if I can't use this power at all - if at all, then at most when accelerating.
But you're right, different mentalities apply. That's not meant to be mean or critical at all.
 
#19 ·
Hats off, @ApocalypsePopcorn - you've got some seriously-sized spherical appendages to have done that. Kudos.

I'm still trying to come to terms with the 6MT gear spacing. I complain that 1st is low (but has proven perfect on steep forest roads), the massive in between the 1st and 2nd makes WOT acceleration tedious, and the difference in between the 5th and 6th is just ridiculously small (yet a taller 6th would make it useless on any hill). Oh well, another Subaru quirk..
 
#21 ·
What is the legal background in Australia for changing a car's gearbox like this?
Do you have to go to any official technical check after the change?
Does the change of gearbox have to be entered in the registration papers?
Both are mandatory in Germany and in the EU as well. In particular, the technical inspection as a so-called individual acceptance would be expensive.
 
#24 ·
Sorry, I was hiking for a month and missed this comment, and then forgot it was there.

The gearbox has been fantastic for me. We've done some medium offroading that would have been impossible without it. I'm still loving the gear spacing and tactile feedback of a solid linkage.

My next challenge is that the engine is increasingly using oil. 7l/100km, to be precise. I've been down a rabbit hole on the oil use issues, and the culprit seems to be the oil control piston rings. I'm about to do a bunch of engine cleaning stuff (double oil change with flushes, fuel cleaner additive and italian tune-up) to see if that makes a difference. In the event that it doesn't I've put the same hat I was wearing when I did the gearbox swap back on, and researching what's involved in swapping to a post-2014 FB engine. I'm leaning heavily towards an FB25 swap; apart from the obvious power benefits, I think it would lead to less clutch slipping to make up for the weaksauce FB20, reduced fuel consumption has been reported after that swap, and I'd imagine that needing to push it less hard would also mean less oil consumption (from the separate issue that all post-EJ engines have been built with looser tolerances because Subaru is chasing fuel efficiency at the expense of engine longevity and oil consumption)
 
#25 ·
Thanks for the update. I think my last concern is how the ABS handles the 2WD mode in high range. My mind is thinking about how the ABS will activate the rear brakes to get the front spinning but no power to front.

This is also an expensive proposition in the US since I would need to get the trans shipped from down under. I will see how I feel once my warranty expires . . .
 
#26 ·
I'm not sure I'm following you. I don't think there's any difference between the gearboxes from the AWD/ABS point of view. Certainly I've been in plenty of wheel-slipping situations in both high and low and the system has performed as expected, getting me traction.
Sorry, I just woke up. Brain not work yet.
Pretty sure I've got a spare dual range shifter kicking around if you decide to do it. I think you'd struggle to find the centre console with room for the lever in a left hand drive version, but you could probably mount it under the dash or something.
 
#27 ·
Glad to hear about your experiences with wheel slippage. Thanks for the offer for the shifter. I am not too sure it would even work for me. Since I have a 2nd Gen Crosstrek, I would probably need to fab something special. Besides having a left-hand steer, the console is significantly different. I was looking at getting a trans from ADS (LINKY) which can also supply some of the trim.
 
#29 · (Edited)
I'm looking at things I've been meaning to do but neglecting on my XV and one thing is that the shifter assembly (which I believe came out of a Liberty/Legacy, but it's hard to recall. I think I grabbed a Forester one too, which wasn't any better) didn't fit quite right. It bolted in fine, but the position of the gear stick is too far forward and juuuust makes contact with the plastic of the console in gears 1, 3 and 5.
I remembered the comment above about the EU 1.6l XV coming with dual range, and I poked around and found one of theirs: SUBARU XV 1 generation (2011-2017) Gear Shifting Knob 35016AG011, 35011AG011 20992828 - Used parts online - 8511456 | Partversal.co.uk
Possible part numbers: 35016AG011 35011AG011 20992828.
That would be a complete assembly, and the dual range lever looks like it would bolt in place properly, rather than the lazy bracket thing I "fabbed" up.
Looks like maybe an Imprezza shifter assembly is commensurate with that EU shifter, and would fit better. Which, in retrospect; fucking duh.
Unfortunately, after years of government regulation chipping away, self-service wrecking yards no longer exists in Australia (at least within a day's drive of where I live) so playing "poke around until you find what you're looking for" will no longer be a pastime I can enjoy.