So is this right or wrong?
drivers side [Front Left]:
White w/ Black stripe- POS
Blue w/ Orange stripe- NEG
Passengers side [Front Right]:
Green wire- POS
Brown w/ White stripe- NEG
You have the wrong polarity on both of those. See audio wiring diagram I just added to my previous post, and compare to HU's speaker outputs. At the HU, the
higher pin number of each speaker's wire pair is (+). E.g., on pin 7 & 8 pair (Front Left), 8 is (+).
Subaru's wiring diagrams give me a headache when they change wire colors like on your fronts (trace through the junction connectors to see what I'm talking about). At least the rears are sane.
On this model/year, it looks like each of the door speakers' pin #1 is (+). Each of the tweeters' #1 is (-).
Could you post some better pictures of various sides of those speaker harnesses you cut out, with no fingers, so we can better see what pins Subaru considers to be 1 and 2?
As for Metra's speaker harnesses, I suspect that the polarities may not be standard across all cars' harnesses that they fit. It could change between different makes, and possibly even on different models/years within the same make. And/or, you can't always assume that Metra's black wire means "negative". That is definitely the case in the car's factory wiring.